Apple Crisp Cookies With Oat Crumble

These apple crisp cookies start with a thick brown sugar cookie base and are topped with finely diced cinnamon apples and a buttery oat crumble. They are large, bakery-style cookies that bake to about ½ inch thick with golden brown bottoms and a soft apple centre.

The cookies have the caramel flavour of my butterscotch cookie recipe, with the apples and oat topping giving them the flavour and slight apple-pie feel of homemade apple crisp. They are also a practical fall recipe when you only have a cup of usable apple rather than enough to make a pie or full-sized apple crisp.

The firm brown sugar cookie dough gives these cookies their caramel-like base. For another thick cookie caramely cookie with brown sugar, see my brown sugar chocolate chip cookies.

Quick Answer

Apple crisp cookies are brown sugar cookies topped with fresh cinnamon apples and a buttery oat crumble. The firm cookie base is similar in texture to a peanut butter cookie and holds the softer apple topping without becoming a miniature pie.

I grew up gleaning apples from old orchards along the back roads of Northern Ontario, so learning to use what was available—even fallen apples—was instilled in me early. That kind of practical, make-do cooking is nothing new. Early settlers used the food they could gather and preserve, and there is no reason to waste a sound apple simply because it fell from the tree or doesn’t look perfect.

I wash and inspect each apple carefully, then generously cut away bruises, worm holes and other damaged areas. Apples that are mouldy, rotten or contaminated should be discarded. The good, firm portions can be used immediately in these cookies, frozen for later baking or used in another practical recipe such as my apple tea bread. Apples that are too soft for dicing may be better suited to a cooked recipe such as small-batch apple butter, provided they are still sound and safe to use.

Why You’ll Love These Apple Crisp Cookies

Uses imperfect apples: Damaged areas can be cut away before the usable apple is finely diced.

No apple filling to cook: The cinnamon apples are placed on the cookies raw and soften as they bake.

Bakery-Style Cookies: These are large, thick cookies that bake to about ½ inch with golden brown bottoms, soft cinnamon apples and a buttery oat crisp topping.

Fall flavour without making a pie: The cinnamon apples and oat topping provide the flavour of apple crisp in individual cookies.

How to Make Apple Crisp Cookies

Preheat the oven to 375°F and line your cookie sheets with parchment paper. Although these cookies can be baked at a higher temperature, I use 375°F so the brown sugar edges and oat topping do not burn before the cookies are finished.

Add the softened butter, brown sugar and eggs to a large mixing bowl. Cream them together until the butter is evenly blended and no large buttery streaks remain.

In a second bowl, combine the flour, salt, baking soda, baking powder and 1 teaspoon of cinnamon. Mixing the dry ingredients separately distributes the baking soda, baking powder, salt and cinnamon evenly before they are added to the wet ingredients.

Gradually add the dry ingredients to the creamed mixture, then add the vanilla. Mix until a firm dough forms. This dough is drier than many drop-cookie doughs, so do not expect it to be loose or sticky.

Cover and chill the dough for at least 30 minutes. Chilling firms the butter and makes the dough easier to shape. It also helps control spreading once the cookies enter the oven.

While the dough chills, place the finely diced apples in a third bowl. Add the granulated sugar and the remaining teaspoon of cinnamon, then stir until the apple pieces are evenly coated. Dice the apples small enough that they can soften during the short baking time and sit neatly in the centre of each cookie.

In a fourth bowl, combine the oats, butter and brown sugar. Work the butter through the oats and sugar until the mixture begins to hold together in small pieces. The butter should be soft enough to combine but not melted.

Roll the chilled dough into 19–20 balls and arrange them on the prepared trays with plenty of room between them. The dough is firm, but the cookies will still spread somewhat.

Press each dough ball down slightly, then make an impression in the centre as you would for a thumbprint cookie. Do not press the entire cookie completely flat. The impression creates a shallow space to hold the apples and oat crumble.

Spoon some of the cinnamon apples into each impression. Add the oat crumble over the apples, keeping most of it inside the centre of the cookie.

Bake for 8–10 minutes. The cookies are ready when the outside edges are lightly browned and the cookie base looks set. The apple and crumble centre will remain softer than the outside edge.

Allow the cookies to sit on the tray briefly before moving them. The topping is soft and hot immediately after baking, while the cookie base becomes firmer as it cools.

Ingredients for Apple Crisp Cookies

These cookies have three simple parts: a brown sugar cookie base, a fresh cinnamon apple centre and a buttery oat crumble.

Butter: One cup goes into the cookie dough, while another half cup binds the oat crumble. The butter should be softened but not melted.

Brown Sugar: Two cups sweeten the cookie dough and create its butterscotch-like flavour. Another half cup is used in the oat topping.

Eggs: Two eggs bind the firm cookie dough.

All-Purpose Flour: Three and a half cups give the cookies enough structure to support the fresh apple topping.

Salt: Half a teaspoon balances the sweetness of the brown sugar and apple topping.

Baking Soda: One teaspoon encourages browning and helps the cookies spread.

Baking Powder: Half a teaspoon provides a small amount of lift so the cookies do not bake into heavy discs.

Vanilla: One teaspoon rounds out the brown sugar flavour in the cookie base.

Cinnamon: Two teaspoons are divided between the recipe. One teaspoon goes into the dry ingredients to flavour the brown sugar cookie base, and the remaining teaspoon seasons the diced apples.

Fresh Apples: Dice approximately one cup very finely. The peel can remain on as long as damaged or tough portions are removed.

Granulated Sugar: Two tablespoons draw out some of the apple juice and help coat the pieces with cinnamon.

Cinnamon: One teaspoon seasons the apples rather than the entire cookie dough.

Quick Oats: Two cups form the buttery oat streusel that gives these cookies their apple crisp topping. Quick oats create a finer crumble that sits easily over the small apple centres. Read my guide to quick oats versus old-fashioned oats if you are unsure which package you have.

Substitutions and Add-Ins for Apple Crisp Cookies

This recipe relies on the firm brown sugar base and oat topping for its apple crisp identity, so substitutions should be kept fairly simple.

Butter: Salted or unsalted butter can be used. If using salted butter, the added salt can be reduced slightly if desired. Margarine and spreadable tub products contain different amounts of water and may change how the cookies spread.

Brown Sugar: Light or dark brown sugar can be used. Dark brown sugar will give the cookies a deeper molasses flavour and slightly darker colour.

Eggs: An egg-free replacement has not been tested in this firm cookie dough. Because the eggs provide structure and moisture, replacing them could noticeably affect shaping and spreading.

All-Purpose Flour: Alternative flours have not been tested. A gluten-free flour or whole wheat flour may absorb moisture differently and could make the already-firm dough too dry.

Fresh Apples: Use firm pieces cut from any sound baking or eating apple. A tart apple will contrast more strongly with the brown sugar base, while a sweeter apple will give the topping a softer apple flavour.

Granulated Sugar: The small amount of sugar can be reduced if the apples are particularly sweet, although the topping may release and caramelize differently.

Cinnamon: Apple pie spice can replace the cinnamon, but it will introduce additional spices and change the simple apple crisp flavour.

Oats: Quick oats and old-fashioned oats absorb moisture differently. Use the same type throughout the batch and expect larger rolled oats to create a coarser topping.

Vanilla: Vanilla can be omitted if necessary, although the brown sugar base will taste less rounded.

Optional Nuts: Chopped walnuts or pecans could be added to the oat crumble if desired. Keep the pieces small so the topping remains inside the cookie centre.

Expert Tips, Serving and Storing Suggestions

Tip #1: Dice the Apples Finely: The cookies only bake for 8–10 minutes. Large apple chunks may remain too firm and can fall from the centre when the cookie is moved.

Tip #2: Expect a Firm Dough: The dough is drier than a typical drop-cookie dough. Chill it, roll it into balls and press the centre rather than adding liquid to make it softer.

Tip #3: Leave Space Between Cookies: These are shaped cookies, but the brown sugar dough still spreads. Crowding the tray can cause the edges to join.

Tip #4: Keep the Topping Centred: The thumbprint-style impression gives the apples and oat mixture a place to sit. Topping spread over the outer edge is more likely to fall off or brown too quickly.

Serve apple crisp cookies once they have cooled enough for the base and topping to set. They work well as a fall dessert, an after-school treat or something to serve with coffee or tea. For another way to bring fresh apple flavour into fall baking, try my apple spice cookies. My apple chai streusel muffins are another option when you want fresh apples with a crumbly streusel topping.

Because the cookies contain a moist fresh apple topping, allow them to cool completely before storing them. Keep them in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to four days. Separate layers with parchment paper so the oat topping does not stick to the bottoms of the cookies above it.

Bring refrigerated cookies to room temperature before serving if you prefer a softer centre. Freezing the completely assembled cookies has not been tested.

These apple crisp cookies are a practical way to use the good portions of apples that might otherwise be wasted. What kind of apple did you use, and did you leave the peel on or remove it?

Meet Amber

I’m the home cook and recipe creator behind A Cents For Cookery. I learned to cook growing up off-grid in Northern Ontario, where meals were made on a woodstove and preserving, baking, and making ingredients stretch were part of everyday life. Here I share practical family recipes, homemade baking, vintage-inspired cooking, and the kitchen knowledge I’ve picked up over the years to help you make the most of the food you have.

Learn more about me →